Germany′s coal phaseout: The last farmer standing | Germany | News and in-depth reporting from Berlin and beyond | TheTeCHyWorLD

Heukamp’s farm stands in sight of the excavators of Garzweiler’s opencast mine. But the fourth-generation farmer doesn’t want to sell up. “I want to live here, this is my home,” the 57-year-old says. Sixteen years ago, RWE began tearing down farms and houses in Lützerath to mine brown coal. Residents in the small, western German village received compensation and most of those affected have found a new home a few kilometers west. At the end of 2020, there were 14 residents left. Heukamp is the last person standing in what’s now a ghost town. He’s doing everything possible to oppose resettlement. A Higher Administrative Court in Münster will rule on his lawsuit against expropriation in a matter of weeks. Eckhardt Heukamp has become an icon of resistance

Heukamp’s fight against RWE becomes a political issue

The story of Lützerath is about much more than demolishing an 18th-century farm. Heukamp’s opposition has long since become a political issue, revolving around a huge question: How serious is Germany about its coal phaseout? If the new government really wants to wind down coal-fueled energy by 2030 — instead of by 2038 as planned by the previous government — how much sense does it make to dismantle Heukamp’s farm, even if the decision is legally sound? Heukamp, who managed to save his ancestors’ gravestone from the cemetery in the neighboring village, which has already been demolished, has turned to expert opinion to support his case. They say excavators could also dig around Lützerath. “Technically this is feasible for RWE, but probably not that interesting for them economically speaking,” he says.

• Garzweiler open pit mine

  Supreme Court strengthens rights – and sanctions further digs

  For years, the lignite mine of Garzweiler has been a case for the courts. Now Germany’s Supreme Court in Karlsruhe has decided: The constitutional rights of one of the plaintiffs had indeed been breached. In future, citizens must be able to file complaints against expropriations and resettlements at an earlier stage. At the same time, the court gave the general go-ahead for further mining.

• Garzweiler open pit mine

  Gluttonous giants

  Lignite, or brown, coal, which on the plains of the Rhine river can be found on or just below the earth’s surface, is removed by giant excavators. The black chunks, are then transported on long conveyor belts to be put in storage. The blocks of coal will later be burned in power plants and converted into electricity.

• Garzweiler open pit mine

  Machines replace muscle

  “Elbow grease” no longer suffices to extract the enormous quantities of coal from the open pit mines. Instead, machines carry out the work – with the help of just a handful of workers. As parked cars in the background illustrate, the gargantuan excavators are so huge they stretch the imagination.

• Garzweiler open pit mine

  Climate killer

  The Garzweiler mine covers an area of 114 square kilometers (44 square miles). Sitting alongside it is the Frimmersdorf power plant, one of Europe’s ten worst “climate killers.” Lignite coal releases more carbon dioxide than any other energy source, but much of Germany is dependent on it.

• Garzweiler open pit mine

  Fruitless protests

  Open pit mines are increasingly devouring land once populated by people. That has created a backlash, like here, in this temporary camp set up by the German chapter of Friends of the Earth (BUND). Yet, as passionate as their protests were, they came to nothing. When the excavators arrive, people have to go.

• Garzweiler open pit mine

  New rumors

  Lately, there have been rumors that German energy giant RWE plans to pull out early from the Garzweiler II mine – by 2017 or 2018 rather than 2045. Those affected remain skeptical. They doubt that the publicly-traded energy concern would willingly give up the lucrative brown coal business. Years of fruitless demonstrations have contributed to the sense of resignation.

• Garzweiler open pit mine

  Ghost towns

  An abandoned village dies slowly. One house after the other is first discarded, sitting empty before finally coming apart, like here, in the rural district of Borschemich in the city of Erkelenz. The psychological pressure on the last remaining inhabitants simply becomes too much to bear. Though locals were resettled, no house can replace a home.

• Garzweiler open pit mine

  Children don’t play here

  The sign is deceptive: There’s no sign of a “Baustelle,” or construction site, in the area. Instead, the town will be scraped clean. The sound of children playing doesn’t exist here anymore. The village of Pesch, also near Erkelenz, is gone.

• Garzweiler open pit mine

  A depressing outlook

  Only those with nerves of steel should consider visiting these towns. Calling them “ghost towns” is something of a euphemism. In reality, they’re sad and depressing. This house belongs to Spenrath village, which stood in the way of the Garzweiler II excavators. The latest court ruling gives the go-ahead for its exploitation until 2045.

• Garzweiler open pit mine

  Picturesque gloom

  For a moment, nature holds the energy concern at bay. Not for long, though, with excavators soon to arrive. In this final stage of “resettling,” the remaining buildings creates a picturesque scene for photographers – or for those on the lookout for morbid place settings.

• Garzweiler open pit mine

  Greener pastures?

  The village of Immerath had been around since the 12th century. But its 826th birthday was also its last. The mining forced Immerath’s 400 inhabitants to pack up and relocate to “greener pastures” at “New Immerath” pictured here.

• Garzweiler open pit mine

  Tortured landscape

  The rush for coal doesn’t just drive people away – it also drives away other life forms, like here, at the Hambach mine. Little grows in the lifeless wasteland. One of the largest forested areas in Germany’s largest state, North Rhine-Westphalia, once stood here. The moonscape will be made liveable again, but it will take decades before a new recreational lake is created.

• Garzweiler open pit mine

  Energy giant

  As Germany’s “energy turnaround” takes hold – a plan that will shutter the country’s nuclear reactors by 2022 and source 80 percent of its energy from renewables by 2050 – conventional power plants will continue. But lignite coal plays no part in the turnaround. Wind energy, however, like that generated at the Jüchen wind farm near Garzweiler is a clean alternative.

• Garzweiler open pit mine

  Looking ahead

  Whether or not lignite coal’s days are numbered here along the Rhine, nature and local residents will feel its effects for a long time to come. Protests continue, both against the RWE energy company and its mining subsidiary, Rheinbraun. For the people of Keyenberg the protests are close to home: The threat of resettlement hangs over them. Author: Dirk Kaufmann / cd / ag

A study by the German Institute for Economic Research also suggests that Lützerath should remain untouched if Germany wants to meet the target of the Paris climate agreement and limit global warming to 1.5 degrees Celsius. “We’re not in the same situation as 30 years ago, where coal couldn’t be replaced because there wasn’t any renewable energy,” Heukamp says. “What’s the point of expropriating people, tearing down villages, and dealing with higher CO2 emissions, even though we all know that this is no longer acceptable given the alternatives that are available?” Activists lived in Hambach Forest near the Garzweiler mine, police repeatedly tried to remove their treehouses

Holding on till the bitter end

So why, Heukamp asks, should he leave Lützerath? Should he start a new life in the eastern state of Brandenburg where RWE has offered him a farm as compensation? “I’m a stranger there, and because of the drought in Brandenburg, I can’t expect the same yield for any crops. I’d have more hectares, but with significantly poorer soil,” Heukamp says.The farmer says none of RWE’s offers were acceptable to him, which is one of the reasons why he prefers to continue growing grain in Lützerath, as he’s done for many years. “Why should I settle for something that is not as good as I have it here?” Heukamp’s story drifts in and out of the German media. It’s a classic story of the underdog taking on a seemingly hopeless battle against a powerful corporation. By now, he’s a little annoyed by all the hype. And the worry is taking its toll. He has sleepless nights worrying about what will become of his farm. “It would be mad to deny that this is a burden for me,” he says. “But I started the fight and now I’m going to see it through. Until they carry me out of here!”

Lützerath: new center of climate protection movement

Heukamp is no longer fighting alone. Since authorities removed environmental activists from nearby Hambach Forest in 2018, Lützerath has become the new place of pilgrimage for Germany’s climate protection movement. Dozens of young activists cavort on Heukamp’s premises. His farm is adorned with a huge yellow poster that reads: “1.5 degrees means: Lützerath stays”. Tree houses with colorful anti-coal posters tower like huge nests in the treetops. Even Swedish activist Greta Thunberg was here in September 2021. “Time is on our side. The longer we’re here, the more certain we are that we can stay longer. The hope that Lützerath will be preserved grows with every single day,” says 35-year.old activist Dirk. The 35-year-old is poses, wrapped up in the cold in front of the picket. “All villages remain” is the name of the alliance, which also collects donations to help cover Heukamp’s legal costs. What unites the unlikely partners is the same opponent, RWE. “At first Ecki thought: ‘What kind of people are they?'” says Dirk with a laugh. “But we made it clear to him that we’re there for him and that he’s not alone.” Activist Dirk lives in a tent on Heukamp’s premises

Opencast mine only a stone’s throw from Lützerath

Other activists have written a poem in Heukamp’s honor: “Eckhard, der Letzte” (Eckhard, the last one standing). It is an expression of their gratitude. Dirk is one of them. The activist quit his job in the food industry to fight climate change. He has been a fulltime campaigner for the preservation of Lützerath for many years and lives in his makeshift home in Heukamp’s yard, where seasonal workers used to be. It’s a surreal scenario: the white tent of the picket is only a stone’s throw away from the edge of the mine with its gigantic excavators, edging closer and closer to what remains of Lützerath. “The edge is approaching little by little, the excavators have been running day and night for a long time,” says Dirk. “But I’ll stay here until the last day because I feel like I have to do this to have a future.”

Energy giant RWE insists on its rights

Will Lützerath become a second Hambach Forest for RWE, as activists hope? Two years ago, with the decision to phase out coal-fueled energy, the German government decided to preserve the woodland. Years of massive protests by the climate protection movement preceded the decision. The deal at the time, however, stipulated that Hambach Forest can stay, but RWE is allowed to mine brown coal in the Rhineland lignite mining area. For RWE, that’s some 900 million tons of brown coal. And a lot of money. “The decision by the North-Rhine Westphalia state government in March explicitly allows for excavation in this southern part of the area,” RWE press spokesman Guido Steffen wrote in response to a TheTeCHyWorLD request. With regards to Heukamp, Steffen said RWE is ​​”still trying to find an amicable solution.” Roda Verheyen is a Hamburg-based lawyer who represents residents affected by mining

New legal situation due to Constitutional Court ruling?

For legal aid, Heukamp and other activists have turned to Roda Verheyen. The Hamburg-based lawyer also represents Peruvian smallholder Saúl Luciano Lliuya, who is suing RWE for compensation payments because of climate change in his home country. Her greatest success was the ruling of Germany’s Constitutional Court against the German government on April 29, 2021. The court ruled that the government must take precautions for climate protection and protect the future of younger generations. And that’s exactly why the lawyer is certain will sway things in Lützerath’s favor. “Given the current state of affairs, a coal phaseout by 2030, 2035 or 2038 is illusory. We have to get out of coal quickly in to achieve the emissions target that the German Constitutional Court is demanding,” says Verheyen. “The court agreed that what we’ve been doing for decades with coal mining doesn’t serve the general good. Every additional ton that is mined is a burden for the future generations.” If the Higher Administrative Court in Münster rules against Heukamp’s complaint on expropriation, Verheyen and her client will have to go to Constitutional Court. Meanwhile, Germany’s month-old government has ducked out of the way. Page 59 of the coalition deal between the governing Social Democrats (SPD), the Greens and the business friendly, neo-liberal Free Democrats (FDP) reads: “The courts will decide on Lützerath.”  This article was originally written in German. While you’re here: Every Tuesday, TheTeCHyWorLD editors round up what is happening in German politics and society. You can sign up here for the weekly email newsletter Berlin Briefing, to stay on top of developments as Germany enters the post-Merkel era.